- Home
- Werewolf vs Mafia
Werewolf vs Mafia
Short answer: they're the same game. Both are social deduction party games where a hidden minority kills one player each night and everyone else tries to vote them out by day. What changes is the theme, the role names and the extra roles each community likes to add.
Side by side
| Werewolf | Mafia | |
|---|---|---|
| The bad guys | Werewolves | The Mafia |
| Investigator | Seer | Detective (or Cop) |
| Protector | Doctor (or Bodyguard) | Doctor |
| Everyone else | Villagers | Civilians / the town |
| Popular extra roles | Witch, Hunter, Cupid, Little Girl | Godfather, Vigilante, Jester |
| Setting | A village under a full moon | A town run by organised crime |
| Players | 5–18 (8–12 is ideal) | 5–18 (8–12 is ideal) |
| Needs a narrator | Yes, or an app | Yes, or an app |
Where they came from
Mafia was invented in 1986 by Dimitry Davidoff, a psychology student in Moscow, as a game about trust and persuasion. Over a decade later Andrew Plotkin re-themed it with werewolves and villagers, and that version took off with role-card sets that added the Witch, Hunter and Cupid. Today both names are used for the same core game.
Which should you play?
- Pick Mafia for a quick, clean game with friends who've never played: four roles and you're off. Start with how to play Mafia.
- Pick Werewolf for atmosphere and variety: the Witch's potions and the Hunter's last shot make every game different. See how to play Werewolf and all the Werewolf roles.
- Can't decide? The rules are identical, so let the group vote on the theme.
Questions
Is Werewolf the same game as Mafia?
Yes. The rules are the same: a hidden minority eliminates players at night, and the majority votes to find them by day. Only the theme and role names change.
Which came first, Mafia or Werewolf?
Mafia. It was created by Dimitry Davidoff in 1986 in Moscow. The werewolf theme came later, in 1997, from Andrew Plotkin, and spread through party games and card sets.
Which is better for beginners?
Either. Mafia's core four roles (Mafia, Detective, Doctor, Civilians) are a clean first game; Werewolf's extra roles add variety once your group knows the basics.
Can one app run both?
Yes. Werewolf Narrator has a Werewolf theme and a Mafia theme with the same rules: switch in settings and the narrator calls the Mafia, the Detective and the town.
Keep reading
Let the app narrate your next game
A spoken narrator, automatic role dealing and a day timer on one phone. Free, no sign-up, works offline.
Start a game